Wednesday, February 19, 2014

The Last shall be first- James Buchanan a very unpopular president.

Ha! I told myself I was going to read an adult biography of every president by the end of the year. I would only have to read something like 3.58333 a month to make my goal. I thought with enough spare time and the use of audio books, it seemed a very manageable goal.

Again I repeat, HA! Here it is in February and I've just finished my first one! And since yesterday was President's day, I should at least post my first review. I'm reading the biographies in order of the presidents popularity, starting with the least popular and saving "the best for last"



 James Buchanan 15th  POTUS  43 out of 43





James Buchanan was an experienced politician and well qualified candidate for president. He had been involved with the admiration of 10 presidents before him in one way or another.  He had severed in the state legislation of Pennsylvania before being elected as a congressman. President Andrew Jackson appointed him Minister to Russia. He served as secretary of state under James K. Polk. He was later than appointed as Minister to Great Britain under the administration of his predecessor Franklin Pierce.

So how could such an intelligent man with an impressive resume utterly fail in his duties as President of the United State?

James Buchanan, 15th President of the United States…and our most unpopular president.
If the presidency were like high school, Buchanan would be the lowest man on the totem pole. His former allies, the more popular kids would refuse to acknowledge him. He burned too many bridges during his presidency. The freaks and geeks wouldn't even let him sit with them at lunch. In my mind, Buchanan would be that miserable scab eating his lunch in the bathroom stall, wringing his hands and plotting. “One day, I’ll show them! I’ll show them all!”

Buchanan had his chance and he really blew it. He is mostly known for the administration that was responsible for the collapse of the Union and the start of the Civil War. While he had to deal with a snowball effect of states’ rights and secessionist issues from previous presidents, his actions only escalated the foreseeable conflict. Really his in-actions were the main cause. His other claim to fame was that he was are only bachelor president and also rumored to be our only gay president.

James Buchanan had grand plans for the country when he took the oath of office. Unfortunately, none of them seemed to involved taking care of the problems we already had. The United States at the time in its adolescent. By that I mean, like a gangly teenager it was growing so fast that you couldn’t keep them in clothes that fit and your fridge was always empty.  During his service on Polk’s cabinet, Buchanan helped expand US territory by 1.2 million square miles.  During his administration, three new states were added to the Union; Minnesota, Oregon and the notorious “bloody Kansas” Buchanan’s bungling of the expansion of the Union and the unwillingness to address the issue of slavery led us into a right kerfuffle.

Some argued that Buchanan’s services to his country overseas before he became president led him to be out of touch with the slavery issue. He let the courts tackle the issue of slavery in the infamous Dred Scott decision. I think Buchanan was very well aware of the issues at hand, but didn’t want to make a firm statement or action on them to avoid stirring up controversy. That strategy works pretty well when you are trying to avoid a watercolor debate about sports teams, or TV shows. But not when you are the leader of the country. Sometimes you have to get your hands dirty.

 Buchanan opposed the idea of slavery. He was determine to uphold the law, even the law of slavery in the South,(“domestic intuition”) so abolitionists and runaway slave were no more than law breakers in his eyes. Oh and he really did not like black people  (“James Buchanan doesn't care about black people.”) And not in the same sense of most whites in the country thought black and slaves were inferior. In his third address to Congress in December 1859, he suggested that all black males were no more than “rapists and arsonists “. Buchanan’s appeasements to the southern states helped the Confederacy grow stronger and more powerful. If his administration had not been so lax, the Civil War could have been ended much sooner, if not be avoided entirely.

But if you think Buchanan just sat on his hands and let the world crash around him, think again. I think it would be easy to say that he was a bit mad with power. He wanted to expand the United States further southward including plans to expand into Mexico and buy Cuba. In his last address to Congress, as several southern states were leaving the Union, he had the gall to ask for $30 million dollars to purchase Cuba, even though Spain (who owned it at the time) had no interest in selling it.
He sent troops into Utah in order to expand the territory and admit it as a state. The problem was the Mormon settlers didn’t want to give up their land. Too bad there would have been no compromise for Buchanan because guess what; he really hated Mormons too.  He also sent large fleet (19 warships and several thousand sailors) to “punish” the country of Paraguay for supposedly firing on an American ship. Obviously, a military force of that magnitude should have been patrolling the coastal boarder of the southern states as civil unrest grew.

We might have avoided this all. James Buchanan almost didn’t live to become president. A few months before his inauguration, he was living in a Washington hotel where he contracted dysentery. A few of his party died from the disease, but he survived. Which bring to question, what would happen if a president elect died before he could take the oath of office? Would the vice president take over? Would they let the runner up be president, or would they let the current president stay in office until another special election was held?

In a trend that continued with presidents after him, Buchanan left the White House and the country in more chaos and trouble than when he entered. He is the definition of a lame duck, as he twiddled his thumbs while states dropped out of the Union and the military was left without leadership and running low on supplies. The cost of running his administration and his crazy ideas took up 15% of the federal budget and when Lincoln was elected, James left his a parting present of a $17 million dollar deficit  (oh and a country falling apart)

Buchanan is quoted when addressing Lincoln as he took the White House.  "If you are as happy in entering the White House as I shall feel on returning to Wheatland, you are a happy man." However no one reports Abe Lincoln's reply.  I would guess it went something like this.

"Thanks....you jerk."


No comments:

Post a Comment